'Are We Rich?'

How to handle kids' questions about your finances

September 21, 2010
Source: Getty Image

Share This Story

When your kids ask if you're rich (or poor), what do you say? If you're like many Americans, you may cringe. "Before, money and sex were topics people wouldn't go near. Money still is," says developmental psychologist Nancy Kalish. "It's like the last taboo." Be brave. Here's how you can tackle the issue with your teens:

Figure out why kids are asking. Is the money question coming out of curiosity or anxiety? "If it comes out of anxiety, you want to be as reassuring as you can be about your financial situation," says psychologist Marsha Levy-Warren, author of The Adolescent Journey. Often kids' queries come out of personal concerns. Will they still be able to go to private school now that you've lost your job? Sometimes it's another teen's comment, says Levy-Warren. "For a rich kid you don't dress well," or, "Given where you live, I bet you're rich."

Be honest. "You can limit what you say. But whatever you say has to be true," says Levy-Warren. "If it's a wealthy family, say, 'We're fortunate. We do have resources.'" Or, by contrast, you can say, "'We have to work hard to support ourselves. We do not have a lot of resources financially, but we have other kinds of resources.'"

Know they're comparing themselves to their social circle. They don't necessarily care about the national average. "If their friends have pools in the backyard, and you have a comfortable life but you don't have a pool, the friends seem richer," says Kalish, an emeritus professor of psychology at California State University in Sacramento.

Bring up statistics. Without making your kids' eyes glaze over, you can briefly explain that last year about 44 million Americans lived below the U.S. government's poverty guideline — $22,050 for a family of four. If a child wants to know more, you can explain how people get low-income assistance benefits based on these income levels.

Talk about how money doesn't necessarily buy happiness. People can win the lottery and commit suicide. "Money can make you happier up until $75,000," says Kalish. "After that, it doesn't matter." Indeed, Princeton researchers reported this month in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences that people's emotional well being increases along with their income until $75,000. If they earned more, they felt more successful — but not happier.

Let them know about college finances. "You can say, 'I have a college fund for you. Right now I can cover a year, and I'm trying to save more," says Kalish. Use kids' questions to briefly explain 529 college savings plans (and their tax advantages) and federal financial aid.

Cue up "If I Were a Rich Man." The "Fiddler on the Roof" tune is catchy, and the lyrics are worth discussing. If you were wealthy, would you really not "have to work hard"?

Don't make them feel too responsible. If you're strapped, make sure kids don't think  they're to blame. "You don't want to make it their problem," says clinical psychologist Thomas Merrill, co-author of Settle for More. That is, avoid conveying the message that "if you'd only saved your allowance, we'd have more," he says. 

Explain your values. Feel free to say that even if you were loaded, you wouldn't splurge on, say, a Chanel brooch or $1,400 Christian Louboitin shoes. But don't be too high and mighty about it. Talk about how every family — and every child — has different indulgences. Perhaps your teen is hooked on trendy clothes and desperately wants a new blazer. "If we can't afford the jacket, let's come up with a plan," says Kalish. "It's not just the jacket. That's what parents miss. The jacket is an identity, and the new jacket makes them fit in or not."

Turn questions into teachable moments. They're a great excuse to explain how mortgages and credit cards work. (Check out the Federal Reserve's site.) You can even bring up deferred gratification. (Remember the marshmallow study that asked kids to either eat one sugary confection right away — or wait and get two later?)

Make sure kids know it's not all about money. "It's how you feel about life and yourself," says psychologist Marcella Weiner, author of The Problem Is the Solution: A Jungian Approach to a Meaningful Life. "Then you're always rich."

Related stories:

The Skinny on Allowances

When to Take Kids Off Your Payroll

Should You Let Your Teen Work?

It's the Money, Honey

Why You Should Write (Or Rewrite) Your Will

Should You Even Think About Retiring Early?

How to Cope with a Pink Slip

Share Your Thoughts

For your protection, ensure that no personally identifiable information (like full name or email address) is submitted in your comment.

CAPTCHA
This tests that you are really a person and not a computer.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

Your Privacy

Trust is a cornerstone of our corporate mission, and the success of our business depends on it. P&G is committed to maintaining your trust by protecting personal information we collect about you, our consumers.
Anonymous | Nov 26, 2010
the economy is so bad this past yer so i find this article very helpful considering some families i know are in financial trouble. i think it is important to be realistic with yourself and family. also i agree that money doesn't buy happiness in this article because its true so many people are happy without all the riches!
Anonymous | Sep 24, 2010
Rich I am desperate for money to repay a $2000 loan i gave a family member so they would not lose there home noe they can;t pay, and i know my husband is going to be so mad i'm scared he may leave, if anyone could find it in there heart to send me a few spare dollars, God would bless you too, thank you if you can't or won't say a prayer for me that god sends me someone to help me, I really am very desperate, marilyn lajoie 80 hillview dr bangor me 04401 207-947-4190 my sister thinks i'm an idiot she says no one helps anyone these days, I hopeto prove her wrong, people are good.
applefarmersdaughter | Sep 23, 2010
This has probably been the most horrible year regarding "money" that I have ever experienced. When people say, "there are jobs out there or go get a job" - when you walk the walk in my shoes then we will talk your talk". #1) If you vehicle needs a new clutch - and you need to look for work and there is NO BUS, NO TRANSIT WHERE WE LIVE = walking is the only option. I did try, but I cannot - 13 to 20 miles one way - my feet would be hamburger. #2) It only takes one person to help, but the people or relatives that could, DON'T. They only talk about you, look down upon you - (did I say talk about you yet...?) and make ugly judgement calls. #3) There is no help out there for people that do NOT have children. NONE! #4) FOOD STAMPS: well, if one person has Social Security and the other is looking for work - $160 in food is all you get. No taxables, no toilet paper, tooth paste, shampoo, q-tips, other personal products. NONE. I DON'T UNDERSTAND THAT ONE. #5) I see many others on food stamps, they get $200 per person, in my opinion if you do not know HOW TO PLAY THE GAME, THEY WON'T REMEMBER YOUR NAME! #6) HARDSHIP: WHY ISN'T THERE SOME KIND OF "FUND" FOR THOSE WHO NEED IT, NOT THE S&L'S, NOT THE BANKS OR THEIR EMPLOYEES THAT MAY HAVE GOT LAYED OFF WITH BONUSES THAT COULD PAY 100 FAMILIES RENTAL INCOME FOR 6 MONTHS. THERE IS NO REAL HELP OUT THERE, PEOPLE IN THE HUMAN SERVICES SAY THERE IS, WHERRE? I JUST WANT TO GO TO WORK, I HAVE STOPPED FOOD STAMPS GIVING ME MORE OF INCENTIVE TO GET A JOB. YEAH, THAT WAS AS SMART AS A BANKER CLAIMING HE IS REALLY "BROKE" WHEN, HE JUST BOUGHT THAT BRAND NEW LEXUS CONVERTIBLE. YEAH, I'M BITTER - ITS BEEN TOO LONG FOR MANY OF US, WE JUST NEED A LITTLE HELP. MANY ARE TOO PROUD TO ASK, YEAH - MONEY, MONEY, MONEY. IS THAT WHERE THEY GET THE TERM, "GREEN WITH ENVY"?
NONNIMARTHA | Sep 23, 2010
I am 69 years old, and it is very hard for me to make ends meet. I watch my neighbors that are looking for work, it is said and I totally agree with the above comment. I also like the sort of "arid" humor. I think you should be a writer, whatever job you are looking for - look into being a comic, writer, no I know .... ( I was going to say something harsh, I will leave that to everyone's imagination). Good day.

follow us

Subscribe to Newsletters
X



© NBC Universal Inc. All Rights Reserved  |  Part of the iVillage Lifestyle Network
LifeGoesStrong® is a registered trademark of Procter & Gamble