What Kind of Affair Do You Want?

Can straying ever be good for your marriage?

Source: Getty Images

Share This Story

Tiger Woods is back in the game, heralded by a new TV spot from Nike that seems to put him in the electronic stocks. He stares morosely at the camera as a voiceover recorded by his father at some unknown event asks, "What were you thinking?"

Somehow, his marriage meltdown has spurred a new way of talking about cheating. Instead of focusing only on the heartbreak and loss of trust, psychologists have begun analyzing the different flavors of infidelity. After all, if Tiger, the paragon of clean manliness, can go so far astray, cheating on your spouse might be a bit more complex than a simple case of hot pants.

Psychologist Douglas LaBier claims that, "… cultural attitudes have clearly shifted towards acceptance of affairs. They're seen as a life-style choice; an option for men and women yearning for excitement or intimacy that's lacking or has dulled during their marriage."

He identifies six different kinds of affair, from a kind that's purely emotional and sex-free to one that's rooted in a dysfunctional extended family.

LaBier says that some affairs are actually psychologically healthy — at least for the cheating partner.

An affair can help leverage you out of a destructive or deadened relationship that's beyond the point of renewal. The positive feelings of affirmation and restored vitality generated by an affair can activate the courage to leave a marriage when doing so is healthiest decision for both yourself and your partner. I've seen both men and women become psychologically healthier through an affair. It spring-boarded them into greater emotional honesty and mature action. Of course, you have to be honest with yourself, here, and not rationalize yourself into having the affair while postponing necessary action.

Hmmm. Somehow, we don't think Elin Nordegren sees it that way.

Meanwhile, blogger Av Flox asks, "What Kind of Mistress Are You?" She tells the stories of three different women, none of which has a happy ending — not even the one who ends up marrying the man she was having an affair with.

Tiger will continue to have a successful career, with plenty of lucrative endorsements. He'll probably marry again and even start another family. Nordegren will probably make a new life for herself, as well, while their children will learn to accept that they and their mom weren't enough for their dad.

Is this the kind of affair you want?

Share Your Thoughts

For your protection, ensure that no personally identifiable information (like full name or email address) is submitted in your comment.

CAPTCHA
This tests that you are really a person and not a computer.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

Your Privacy

Trust is a cornerstone of our corporate mission, and the success of our business depends on it. P&G is committed to maintaining your trust by protecting personal information we collect about you, our consumers.
Joe P | Aug 26, 2010
Although the doctor's thoughts could have been worded better, I think is clear: Unless you test the boundaries of your relationship from time-to-time, you'll never be able to know it's strength. If a mere passerby in the street can divert my attention from my partner, that says something; that I find other people attractive.  Big deal, that's life, we're animals.  If she doesn't like it and I persist in her company, that's another thing, but looking is always normal. If I'm married, have an affair, and deliberately, soberly, continue with it, that says something too.  It says the marriage is weak.  It says that the couple doesn't have what it takes for the long haul.  If they did, they'd take time to learn more about each other, do more with each other, and keep life interesting.   That shouldn't be hard between two people who are capable of spending their lives together. And note that I said 'capable' and not 'meant'. Because, really, it's a matter of compatibility, not some romantic notion like fate. Also, why do people feel that marriage holds the connotation of monogamy? I'll tell you why, because the origin of American marriage is Puritan in nature, and that's what they believed.  Somehow, it's pervaded to this day. It doesn't need to be this way. The divorce rate of couples in England and Europe is far less.  It's also well-known that they have a more vibrant swinger culture, and are more accepting to the idea of open marriages. Interesting correlation ... Finding a soul-mate whose company you can enjoy for the majority of you life is what we all want, and THAT is possible.   However, finding one person that you're going to want to have sex with for the majority of your life? THAT is unreasonable.   It's not how we're genetically programmed, and goes against our primal instincts to propagate. I'd argue that two soul-mates who understand this and allow one-another to, occasionally, mingle with other members of the opposite sex on a purely physical basis, will have a far healthier relationship. Now, if they end up meeting someone else who attracts their emotional and psychological attention, that could endanger their relationship. But sex, plain, simple, physical sex without attachments, is something we need, and want to do often with various partners.  This urge can't be erased and, if suppressed, just causes more problems. Look up the work by Dr. Kinsey, or just see his movie, for a real comprehensive and professional approach. I can tell you, though, from personal experience — this really can work!
Susan Kuchinskas | Jun 16, 2010
Sorry, Anonymous, that your first comment wasn't published. Let me assure you that it was not because it "didn't make the cut." It must have been a technical glitch; we only unpublish comments that are explicitly offensive or off-topic. Genuine and constructive criticism is always welcome.
Anonymous | Jun 11, 2010
I'll try this again, since it seems my last attempt at commenting didn't make the cut. What exactly passes as an education in psychology nowadays? Sniffing the wind to decide what the majority thinks is morally acceptable? People become more "honest" "courageous" and "healthier" through lying to their spouses and families? And most likely, lying to some 'other' person as well as themselves? Has this culture really degraded to the point where our best ethical standards are now at the level of logical reasoning and actions one would expect from 14 year-old mall brats? It's now passe to call anything wrong. The only point that counts is whether everyone's doing it. Welcome to eighth grade recess, everyone. Commonly known as the late great USA.
Susan Kuchinskas | May 12, 2010
Well, the title was supposed to be ironic. I do think it's a good thing that we're taking a broader and more nuanced look at marital infidelity. It takes two to do this tango, and simply calling it wrong doesn't change how often it happens. I think it's especially easy for the "other woman" to believe that she's not having an "affair" but rather that she's in love with someone who is in love with her, too — especially if she's younger and not so experienced. It's difficult for a lonely single woman to understand the depth of a marriage and how it is about more than two people sleeping together. Honestly, I agree with you that most of the responsibility falls on the man who breaks his marriage vows.
Anonymous | May 12, 2010
As one who has been betrayed by her "husband" of 22 years for a younger married "women" I hope she learns from this experience. Yes, I like to clue her husband in, yes I love to have a chat with her. She has partnered in changing my lie and my children's lives forever. I hope she spends her days looking over her shoulder wondering if I'll contact her husband..its easy to meet someone with new technology and very easy to locate someone. But it's really not about her..it wouldn't giver her that sense of power..it him..his weakness..his life story. In the end, his isolation. I may be older, but I'm much stronger and I sleep well at night with no need to look over my shoulder.
Anonymous | May 11, 2010
Is there a point to this article? Random typing? The headline in particular is not what I'd expect to find under the heading "FAMILY GOES STRONG"
Anonymous | Jun 29, 2010

Perfectly stated.

Anonymous | Jun 10, 2010

It's amazing the amount of incoherent tripe that passes for 'pychological' knowledge in this current culture.  Let me summarize the good doctor's points:

Having an affair can make you more honest. 

Lying to your spouse and possibly some other person makes you a stronger, more courageous person. 

It's best for all involved (and especially you personally) to leave a marriage that doesn't leave you fulfilled.  Providing you're honest with yourself while lying to your own family.

and lastly, being unable to control your pants will make you a more viable and vigorous human being.

Honestly (insert chuckle), do people even bother to read what they say anymore?  Marriage, as some here have commented, is not something that adjusts itself to your happiness, it asks that you adjust your happiness to it's requirements. 

This entire American culture, of which Tiger is a great example, seems to base it's moral moorings on the brilliant logical musings of your average 14 year old mall brat:  I see, I want, I deserve, I get.  Repeat until sleepy. 

When the Islamofacists finally do takeover, we will have nothing and no one to blame but ourselves for the destruction of this fabulous, sex saturated, pointless, aimless, amoral, Godless enterprise that has become the USA.  

Always remember, Life is always all about YOU.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

follow us

Subscribe to Newsletters
X


© NBC Universal Inc. All Rights Reserved  |  Part of the iVillage Lifestyle Network
LifeGoesStrong® is a registered trademark of Procter & Gamble